Paper snowflakes and candy canes hung from the ceiling, the windows were now the stage for two dimensional happy and peaceful holiday scenes, and a simple, wooden nativity scene — with oversized hay scattered around it — sat in a corner. It was just about as festive and tacky as a two-year-old Sunday school classroom can be in the middle of December.
Several of the kids had taken a shine to the little wooden nativity scene. Each of them picked a character to claim as their own, and began acting out the Christmas story — with some minor artistic licensing, unless of course, there was a Lego family and a T-rex present at Jesus’ birth.
Nate — a cute little boy, who also happened to be the biggest worrier I’ve ever had the pleasure of meeting — had added a plastic black and white dairy cow to the mix of playthings that were reenacting the familiar scene in Bethlehem.
“Teacher, do cows eat this stuff?” Nate asked holding up a few pieces of hay in his chubby, little hand. I said that yes cows do eat hay, so the plastic cow continued munching away on the hay in the feeding trough where the little wooden baby Jesus was sleeping.
Suddenly, panic shot through Nate’s whole body like a bolt of electricity, as he looked down at the toy cow that towered over the manger. He dropped the cow as if he was holding a smoking gun, and asked in a small, shaky voice, “Uh, teacher Kelsey? Was… uh… baby Jesus eaten by a cow?”
If he hadn’t have looked sincerer, I might have burst out laughing. But like a mature and competent Sunday school teacher, I fought hard to hide my amusement, and instead of turning into a laughing hyena, I replied in a confident voice that no, baby Jesus wasn’t eaten by a cow; in fact, he wasn’t eaten by anything.
But my adult manor and reassurance didn’t remove the worry from his mind, and instead, Nate, shot a look of horror at the plastic cow next to his Spiderman shoe. In his mind the cow had become as fearsome as if it had grown fangs and might, at any moment, leap on him and try to suck his blood just like Count Dracula. “I think baby Jesus was eaten by a cow!” he wailed, which caught the attention of the rest of the class.
Slowly, the kids began to scoot away from the nativity, shooting it the same glances you might throw towards the scene of recent crime. Their lips began to quiver, and I knew tears were on the way if I couldn’t reassure them baby Jesus hadn’t been cruelly digested by a dairy cow. I’m honestly not sure they would have been more upset if they’d been told their grandmother was an axe murder.
I tried to explain to my group of little alarmist how we know Jesus wasn’t eaten by a cow when he was a baby, because he grew up into an adult, but after that didn’t work, we had a lengthy discussion about the difference of carnivores and herbivores, and how because cows don’t eat meat, that means they also don’t eat babies.
Vegetarian cows chewing cud rather than gnawing on sleeping, innocent babies consoled all of the little worriers, well, all but Nate who earnestly asked “But what if the cow didn’t see baby Jesus?” He was convinced that some absentminded cow, the size of a house, might have accentually eaten Jesus. After all, Jesus was essentially sleeping in the cows’ food dish.
It’s been several years, but I still can’t help wondering if Nate has a cow phobia; the poor kid.
What a horrible Christmas story it would make if Jesus hadn’t survived “barn life”: God loved the world so much that He sent His one and only Son to Earth, but sadly, He forgot to take into account the giant, baby-eating, dairy cows, so the Son of God became lunch for a hungry cow, because someone let the baby sleep in the cow’s food dish. It sounds more like a Monty Python sketch than the Christmas story when the baby-eater is added. Thankfully, Jesus didn’t end up suck in some cow’s teeth.
Emanuel – God with us – came to be the light into the world, to bring redemption, and thankfully, no, he wasn’t eaten by a cow; not even accidentally.

Recent Comments